Day 26: 1 Kings 17-2 Kings 4 Did Elijah Really Go To Heaven?

Derek Ouellette —  February 10, 2011 — 5 Comments

I was taught in Sunday School class that when Elijah was taken up into heaven from Elisha, that Elijah actually went into Heaven at that time. That is, I was taught that Elijah was “Raptured” and went to Heaven where people float around playing harps and singing hallelujahs for eternity.

I no longer hold that view for three reasons.

1. Elijah had a habit of disappearing via the Spirit of the Lord.

The Scriptures do not tell us when and where Elijah would be “taken” or would “disappear” and then placed somewhere else. That story is untold in the Scriptures but seems to be imbedded into the lower layers of the text and the tradition behind them. For example, Obadiah was in charge of the palace of King Ahab. Elijah met with Obadiah and told him to go and get Ahab. Obadiah’s response is telling:

“You tell me to go to my master and say, ‘Elijah is here.’ I don’t know where the Spirit of the Lord may carry you when I leave you.” – 1 Kings 18:12

If Obadiah’s fear is legit, it seems apparent that the Spirit of the Lord had a habit of taking Elijah up and carrying him to another place. Do you doubt Obadiah’s testimony here? How about the testimony of dozens of legitimate prophets? After Elijah was taken from Elisha a large group of prophets where insistent that they were going to find Elijah somewhere else:

Perhaps the Spirit of the Lord has picked him up and set him down on some mountain or in some valley. – 2 Kings 2:16

These prophets, like Obadiah back in 1 Kings, take it for granted that the Spirit of the Lord would take Elijah up and place him somewhere else (similar to Philip in the New Testament – Acts 8:39-40).

2. “Heaven” usually means “Sky”.

I’m not going to spend much time here since it’s practically a given. The Scriptures make a distinction between “heaven” (i.e. sky and/or outer space) and the “highest heavens” (i.e. the throne room of God) as in, for example 1 Kings 8:27. Genesis 1:20 says the birds fly in the “heavens” (ESV), and in  2 Corinthians 12:2 Paul speaks of going to the “third heaven”.

The point is that “heaven” does not necessarily always refer to that place God’s people go to when they die; and in the case of Elijah, I’m suggest that when he was taken “up to heaven in a whirlwind” that he simply was taken up into the sky and placed somewhere else.

3. Elijah sends a letter after he is taken.

Finally, there is an interesting account written in the parallel telling of 2 Chronicles 21. Now pay attention to this: Elijah was “taken up into heaven” in 2 Kings 2, yet he sent a letter of judgment to the son of King Jehoshaphat (Jehoram) six chapters later, during the story of 2 Kings 8:16-23 (cf. see the account in 2 Chronicles 21:12-15).

Now since Elijah had already been “taken up into heaven” for some time before Jehoram’s reception of the letter we must conclude either a) that Elijah sent it postdated fifteen years or so, or b) Elijah was still on earth somewhere else.

Given the evidence, it seems more likely that Elijah was not Raptured into Heaven, but rather he was taken into heaven (i.e. the sky) and placed down somewhere out of the way – somewhere he could not be found (2 Kings 2:16) – so that Elisha’s ministry could flourish.

The only rapture “mystery” we have left then, is the mysterious Enoch. 😛

Derek Ouellette

Posts Twitter Facebook Google+

a husband, new dad, speaker, writer, christian. see my profile here.
  • http://vagantepriest.blogspot.com/ FrGregACCA

    Reinventing the wheel again… 😉

    The notion that Elias yet lives in the flesh has come down to us, first via the oral tradition of Judaism, and then, of Apostolic Christianity. This is why we note in the gospels an expectation that Elias will appear, and this, of course, leads to speculation as to whether or not John the Baptizer is indeed Elias. In the original Christian Tradition, the “two witnesses” of the Apocalypse are in fact Enoch and Elias. They confront the antichrist, are killed (since they have not died previously), and are then taken up to heaven, body and soul, presumably even as the Theotokos was. Somewhere along the way, certain Dispensationalists picked up this notion as well, but they did not originate it.

    • http://covenantoflove.net Derek

      What does “Orthodox” have to do with “Dispensationalism”? LOL (playing off of Tertullian’s “What does Athens have to do with Jerusalem”)

      The Problem Greg, is that I have just shown you from scripture that the idea that Elijah didn’t die is biblically unsound. Jesus said outright that John was Elijah and that Elijah will come again… that is, the prophetic spirit of Elijah, not the actual person (Matthew 17:11-13).

      And speculation about the “two witnesses”, well … :)

      • http://vagantepriest.blogspot.com/ FrGregACCA

        Well, the Church does not deny it, it is supported by Jewish Tradition and, while it is not dogma, it is the most commonly held theological opinion in the historic Church of both East and West (to the extent that the West is not blinded by a naturalism that would deny such things out of hand).

        Dispensationalism is correct very, very, very occasionally, especially when it has pulled something out of the historical tradition. 😉

    • http://covenantoflove.net Derek Ouellette

      😛 I have to assume that your comment about Dispensationalism being correct “very, very, very occasionally” is a joke. I’ll leave it at that (p.s. I grew up hardcore dispensational! Of all eschatological views in the Historical faith, dispensationalism stands apart as the most absurd and furthest from the Historic faith.)

      And to quote myself one more time, as frustrating for you as it may sound:

      “the idea that Elijah didn’t die is biblically unsound…”

      Since it’s not dogma and since it doesn’t stand up to scripture, I can’t accept it.

  • Rae

    Thank you for your study. I have been searching for the answer and you have the best conclusion based on bible facts I have found.